Suggestion: Time Limit On Editting Thread Titles


sbj

Member
Hey, I didn't know that we can make suggestions. If it is ok, I had one in my mind.

Usually it is not a good idea to allow people to edit their own thread titles, cause threads are known by titles and changes can cause mix ups and irritate people.

But we all make here and then typos, for those cases it would be nice to be able to edit thread titles, without having a moderator to correct it for us or without having the permission to edit thread titles forever.

For that having a time limit of say 5-30 mins (whatever u like) after thread creation would be nice, so people can correct immediately their own typos and such.

What do you think? Thanks.
 

Andy

Administrator
Staff member
You should allow editing posts (which include titles) for a certain period of time, this is the normal thing to do.
 

sbj

Member
Yes, I know. But one want the editting posts time limit much higher than the thread titles.
Because posts can be extended later, people want to add stuff later to the threads. So you want them be able to edit their threads maybe forever, or at least for weeks, so they can come later and add content.

But for thread titles you don't want them to change it much later and screw it up. So to have different time limits for both is best case imo.
 

Andy

Administrator
Staff member
Most forums have a time restriction for editing posts because editing posts days or weeks later is not a good option, members will not realize the post has been updated.
 

sbj

Member
Unless you say in your latest post that you updated the first post. My suggestion was to differentiate between thread titles and posts, as for thread titles the change is only needed for typos mostly, hence a low time limit. And for posts it is usually longer needed as one may add to the first post stuff later, like attachments. Anyway, I just wanted to suggest it, no problem.
 

Andy

Administrator
Staff member
Unless you say in your latest post that you updated the first post.

Nobody will see this new information. That's why it's not a good idea to allow posts to be edit beyond a short time.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
X suggestion for New content limit 1.2 General 4
S Suggestion for Auto Move (what I need) General 1
B Suggestion for First post email General 1
S Suggestion: More RM statistics General 3
Tourmeister Suggestion for "Thread poster review" General 1
M [suggestion] conversation search plus General 5
R Suggestion: Ability to Change default sort for XFRM General 6
X Suggestion new Add-on to Send Email General 0
X [suggestion] Ad manager 1.4 General 4
Robru [suggestion] add-ons for XF2.1 General 1
X Suggestion Add Template to threads General 0
N [Suggestion] Tag manager (in ACP) General 5
X new suggestion for a new add-on General 6
X Suggestion for an addon General 8
Mellow Suggestion for RSVP General 9
A Suggestion Weekly digest General 3
Mellow Suggestion for Calendar General 2
N Suggestion for duplicate user add-on General 1
A Suggestion for an addon General 6
Dave Stromberger [Suggestion] Fix ALL CAPS posts General 3
BassMan [Calendar][suggestion] Today button General 2
kensonplays [Suggestion] Calendar/Countdown Sync General 10
BassMan [suggestion] Bookmark General 0
A [Suggestion] Featured posts add-on, maximum height General 5
S Add-on Suggestion: Alert admin if a link is added to an existing post by a new member General 1
BassMan [suggestion] Email Subscription General 1
BassMan [suggestion] Periodically sending confirmation emails General 16
M Suggestion for Forum Moderators Resource General 1
T Suggestion: Most users online General 3
E Suggestion: Trader: add trader profile to "Message user info elements" General 10
BassMan Weekly Digest [suggestion] General 21
BassMan Quick Search suggestion General 4
pilou suggestion add-ons : Sticky Thread Order General 2
P Add-on suggestion - Thread of the day General 5
T Change date suggestion General 5
S Addon Suggestion: Add member X to member Y's ignore list General 4
Gator [Suggestion] Add "Featured Thread(s)" Widget General 0
mkucuksari Bump Limit Addon Error General 2
J Addon idea: Raise limit of forum title General 5
P Limit characters in RSS feed 1.4 General 9
N Change Limit Error General 1
S New Content Limit General 4

Similar threads

Top